Getty Images
The Cincinnati Bengals have declined the fifth-year option on defensive end Myles Murphy, opting not to lock in a fully guaranteed salary for the 2027 season.
Had the option been exercised, Murphy would have earned roughly $14.5 million that year. Instead, the Bengals are choosing financial flexibility over a fixed commitment—at least for now.
Not a Rejection, A Financial Strategy
This move might look like a step back, but internally, Cincinnati still views Murphy as part of its future.
Director of player personnel Duke Tobin made it clear the decision was rooted in finances rather than performance.
Murphy, still just 24, is coming off his most productive season, recording 5.5 sacks and emerging as a consistent presence on a defense that otherwise struggled. His development late in the year, in particular, gave the Bengals confidence that he’s trending upward.
Declining the option simply avoids a fully guaranteed number and opens the door for a more team-friendly long-term extension.
Cap Implications Behind the Move
Cincinnati’s aggressive roster-building also played a role.
After acquiring Dexter Lawrence II in a major trade, the Bengals have less long-term cap space than usual. Committing $14.5 million to Murphy in a single season—without full elite production yet—was a risk the front office chose not to take.
Instead, they now retain flexibility to negotiate a deal that better reflects his current value and projected growth.
Crowded Edge Room Adds Pressure
Murphy’s future also ties into a deeper defensive line overhaul.
The Bengals have invested heavily in pass rushers, including recent draft picks like Shemar Stewart and Cashius Howell. That influx of young talent creates both competition and insurance at the position.
Murphy is still expected to play a significant role, but he’ll need to continue proving he can anchor the unit.
What Happens Next
Declining the option doesn’t mean Murphy is on his way out—it just shifts the timeline.
If the two sides agree on an extension, he could remain a cornerstone piece for years. If not, Murphy is now on track to hit free agency after the 2026 season, unless the Bengals use the franchise or transition tag.
For a player “just scratching the surface,” as Tobin put it, the next step is clear: turn flashes into consistent production—and force Cincinnati’s hand on a long-term commitment.
More NFL: Buccaneers Exercise Calijah Kancey’s Fifth-Year Option
