Jeremiah Smith makes Heisman case (Photo by Ohio State Athletics)

Jeremiah Smith makes Heisman case (Photo by Ohio State Athletics)

The order is changing every week, but there are a few names and faces who are solidifying their body of work and will be booking tickets to New York as finalists.

1. Jeremiah Smith, Ohio State, Wide Receiver, Junior

It’s different every week this year. Part of that is because no one has seized it yet. Jeremiah Smith did a little in Ohio State’s 28-19 victory over Northwestern. His numbers were solid, reeling in 11 passes for 117 yards and a touchdown. But that’s not why he’s #1 this week. It’s because he showed how much he means to his team. The previous two games, he wasn’t the focal point of the offense (ridiculous, I know). This game, he was, and it opened up everything else. Bo Jackson had over 100 yards and a touchdown rushing. Luke Fahey threw 3 touchdown passes and got his first win. Why? Because Ohio State ran their offense through their best player, who is the best player in the game today. This season, Smith has 80 catches for 1,317 yards and 15 touchdowns.

2. Devon Dampier, Utah, Quarterback, Senior

Smith may have the it factor and mean the most to his team, but Dampier isn’t far behind in what he means to his team. Utah would be good without him, but they wouldn’t be 10-0. The only thing keeping Dampier from being the runaway favorite is that he still turns the ball over, and that could haunt him before all is said and done. Still, he was electric against Arizona. In the top-25 win for the Utes, Dampier was 13 of 25 for 204 yards and 2 touchdowns. He was just as electric on the ground with 14 carries for 100 yards and 2 more touchdowns. Dampier is 185 of 278 for 2,257 yards and 22 touchdowns, with 117 carries for 582 yards and 9 touchdowns on the ground.

3. Darian Mensah, Miami, Quarterback, Junior

It was tough to put Mensah above Carr, seeing as Carr won the game they played head-to-head.  Mensah came up with another big performance and another win in another game without his star receiver Malachi Toney. He was 30 of 41 for 382 yards and a touchdown in the Hurricanes’ victory over Duke. He’s still got at least two, more likely three games left to show what he’s got. That’s an advantage CJ Carr doesn’t have, and that Jeremiah Smith likely won’t have either. So long as Mensah keeps winning, he’ll be in the running for first place and will be a Heisman finalist. Mensah is 242 of 317 for 3,076 yards and 32 total touchdowns (29 passing, 3 rushing).

4. CJ Carr, Notre Dame, Quarterback, Redshirt Sophomore

I jinxed Carr. I talked last week about how he just doesn’t make mistakes, and he threw a pick and got sacked against Boston College. It was only his second interception of the year and his first since September 26th against Purdue. He also got sacked for only the third time this season, his first since September 19th against Michigan State. He was still good! 20 of 28 for 217 yards and 2 touchdowns. Carr is 197 of 290 for 2,385 yards and 26 total touchdowns (23 passing, 3 rushing). I don’t think he has the numbers to win it, but he has the wins and production to be a finalist. Carr will get an invite to New York.

5. Aiden Flora, Iowa State, Running Back, Sophomore

Flora is the nation’s leading rusher right now. He had 28 carries for 216 yards and 3 touchdowns in Iowa State’s victory over Cincinnati. He’s had five games this season where he has earned more than 200 total yards of offense. Flora probably won’t be a Heisman finalist for ISU this year since they’re 5-5, but he’s a start to watch in 2027. This season, he has 185 carries for 1,335 yards and 12 touchdowns. He also has a special teams touchdown.

Helmet Stickers

Memphis quarterback Marcus Stokes was huge in a big weeknight victory for the 8-2 Memphis Tigers. Stokes was 15 of 31 for 313 yards and 3 touchdowns. He also had 8 carries, 73 yards, and 2 touchdowns on the ground. Marcus Stokes’s 5-touchdown game powered the Tigers to a 52-41 win.

Myles Bradley of Bowling Green is the best pass rusher in college football. Bradley single-handedly demolished Kent State this past week. He had 9 tackles, 5 sacks, and a forced fumble. This season, he has 32 tackles, 14.5 sacks, and has forced 4 fumbles. It may not be a Bowling Green, but the man is making himself some money in 2026.

Jeremiah Smith and Jessee Legree get the headlines, but Rasean Jones is on fire in his past three games. Boise State’s best receiver had 11 catches for 230 yards and 3 touchdowns in their win over Oregon State. In his last three games, he has 26 catches for 463 yards and 7 touchdowns.

Leave a Reply