Getty Images
The Cincinnati Bengals’ defensive overhaul reached a boiling point Sunday when veteran linebacker Logan Wilson found himself benched in favor of rookie Barrett Carter. While both players were listed as starters, Wilson played just 20% of defensive snaps in the 27-18 loss to the Green Bay Packers, appearing only on special teams and in the final kneel-down sequence.
Wilson, a cornerstone of Cincinnati’s defense since 2021, admitted Tuesday that he was surprised by the decision.
“I felt like I was [playing well enough to start],” Wilson said. “But obviously [Bengals coach] Zac [Taylor] felt otherwise.”
The change had been brewing for weeks. In the team’s Week 3 loss to the Minnesota Vikings, coaches briefly replaced Wilson with Carter, which the Bengals initially described as an attempt to “lighten his workload.” But Wilson acknowledged at the time that the move hinted at uncertainty surrounding his role.
“I can’t control what their plan is moving forward,” Wilson told ESPN on Sept. 25. “I’m just trying to do my job the best I can and help this defense out.”
Carter’s Emergence and Taylor’s Confidence
Carter, a fourth-round pick from Clemson, logged all 61 defensive snaps against the Packers. His emergence marks a clear shift toward youth and speed within the Bengals’ defense, which has struggled to stop the run and generate turnovers this season.
Head coach Zac Taylor confirmed Monday that the team will stick with Carter moving forward.
“Anytime you put a rookie out there, there’s an element of risk,” Taylor said. “But I just felt he’s proving himself enough to keep getting those reps. We’re going to see constant improvement every single game.”
Carter, for his part, said he remains focused on helping the Bengals end their four-game losing streak.
“No matter what the coaches decide to do, it’s not up to me or him,” Carter said. “But we both love each other. We both go to war with each other.”
A Quiet but Significant Bench Move
While Joe Flacco’s debut and Trey Hendrickson’s injury dominated postgame headlines, Wilson’s reduced role didn’t escape notice. During warmups, observers noted Carter’s increased involvement in base defensive packages. As the game progressed, Wilson’s absence became apparent—especially when he appeared on kickoff coverage rather than defense.
Taylor downplayed the decision as a performance-based rotation rather than a demotion. But the writing may already be on the wall. Wilson’s play has declined this season, with missed tackles and slower reads evident in film study. If new defensive coordinator Al Golden’s system prioritizes speed and versatility, Carter’s promotion could be more than temporary.
The Bigger Picture for Cincinnati’s Defense
Wilson, now in the second year of a four-year, $36 million contract that runs through 2027, has long served as the vocal leader of the Bengals’ defense. But his future with the franchise could hinge on how the unit performs in the coming weeks. The Bengals already parted ways with fellow linebacker Germaine Pratt earlier this year, signaling a willingness to reset their defensive core.
As Cincinnati prepares for Week 7, the message is clear: no starting job is guaranteed. Taylor’s decision underscores a broader effort to inject energy into a defense that has lost its edge since the Bengals’ Super Bowl run two years ago.
For Wilson, the focus remains on professionalism and staying ready. “I’ll just keep doing what I can,” he said. “At the end of the day, I love this team and I’ll do whatever it takes to help us win.”
More must-reads:
Buffalo Bills’ McDermott: Team Must Start From Ground Zero
Brian Branch, JuJu Smith-Schuster Explain Lions-Chiefs Fight
