Getty Images/Ringer illustration
Shohei Ohtani, the baseball phenom, has made headlines yet again with his groundbreaking contract with the Los Angeles Dodgers. Initially touted as a $700 million deal, further details emerged, revealing a highly deferred contract. With $680 million, or 97 percent of the total sum, being deferred, Ohtani’s contract has raised numerous questions about affordability, competitiveness, and the future of free agency in Major League Baseball (MLB).
The Deferral Structure
Understanding MLB’s Collective Bargaining Agreement
According to Article XVI of the MLB collective bargaining agreement, there are no limitations on the amount or percentage of deferred compensation in a player’s contract. This means that teams are free to structure contracts with significant deferrals.
The Dodgers’ Deferred Payment Strategy
The Dodgers took full advantage of this provision in Ohtani’s contract. Initially reported as a $700 million deal, it was later revealed that only $2 million would be paid annually for the next ten years, through 2033. The remaining $68 million per year would be deferred for the following ten years, through 2043. This structure significantly reduces the present-day value of the contract.
The Implications for Competitive Balance Tax
MLB does not have a salary cap, but it does have a competitive balance tax (CBT), which imposes penalties on teams that exceed certain payroll thresholds. Ohtani’s heavily deferred contract impacts the Dodgers’ CBT assessment in a unique way. While the contract’s total value is $700 million, the adjusted average annual value (AAV) for CBT purposes is only $46 million. This lower AAV provides the Dodgers with more flexibility to remain below the CBT thresholds.
No Exploitation of CBT Loopholes
Contrary to popular belief, the Dodgers did not exploit any CBT loopholes with Ohtani’s contract. The confusion arose from the initial description of the contract, which created expectations of a higher AAV. However, the heavily deferred structure was the reason for the lower net present value and subsequent AAV. Ohtani was never going to receive a $700 million AAV, as the contract’s true value was significantly reduced due to the deferrals.
The Significance of Ohtani’s Contract
Ohtani’s Market Value
While the $700 million headline figure is attention-grabbing, it is essential to analyze Ohtani’s market value realistically. Many early projections estimated his market value to be in the $400-$500 million range. Ohtani’s contract, with a net present value of $460,814,764.97, still sets a record, surpassing the previous high AAV contracts signed by players like Mike Trout, Max Scherzer, and Justin Verlander.
Ohtani’s Unique Risk Profile
The Dodgers’ contract offer reflects their evaluation of Ohtani’s unique risk profile. Despite his exceptional talent and star power, the Dodgers were cautious about committing to a $700 million non-deferred contract. The deferrals allowed them to mitigate risk and avoid the winner’s curse. Ohtani’s injury history and the uncertainty of his future two-way performance contributed to the Dodgers’ decision to cap the contract at $460 million.
Ohtani’s Personal Motivations
Ohtani’s decision to accept the deferred contract structure was driven by a combination of personal and team-oriented factors. On a personal level, Ohtani has consistently demonstrated a dedication to winning. He wanted to ensure that the Dodgers had the financial flexibility to build a competitive team around him. Additionally, Ohtani’s endorsement earnings, estimated at around $50 million per year, provide him with financial security in the short term, allowing him to prioritize long-term success over immediate financial gain.
The Dodgers’ Competitive Advantage
The deferred payment structure of Ohtani’s contract provides the Dodgers with a significant competitive advantage. With only a $2 million annual salary for the next decade, the Dodgers have the financial room to make other player acquisitions and strengthen their roster. Ohtani’s request for language in the contract to ensure that the team uses the savings to build a competitive team demonstrates his commitment to the Dodgers’ success.
The Future Implications
The Tax Benefits for Ohtani
One of the advantages of Ohtani’s deferred contract is the potential tax savings it offers him. California’s high income tax rates, which currently stand at 13.3 percent and will increase to 14.4 percent, will not apply to Ohtani’s deferred payments if he no longer resides in the state after his tenure with the Dodgers.
The Dodgers’ Future Financial Responsibility
While the deferred payments may seem less imposing in the distant future, the Dodgers will still have significant financial obligations to fulfill once the bills come due. The team will need to ensure that they have the funds to meet their commitments. They may also explore potential revenue streams from Ohtani-related promotions and advertising to offset these future payments.
MLB’s Stance on Deferred Contracts
MLB has attempted to restrict deferrals in past collective bargaining agreement negotiations. However, the players’ union has advocated for preserving flexibility in contract structures. The future of deferrals in MLB contracts will depend on whether team owners perceive them as a threat to competitive balance and revenue streams. Ohtani’s contract, while unique, does not represent a widespread issue that requires immediate action.
Conclusion
Shohei Ohtani’s deferred contract with the Los Angeles Dodgers has challenged conventional norms in MLB. While initially reported as a $700 million deal, the heavily deferred structure significantly reduced its net present value and adjusted average annual value. The contract raises questions about affordability, competitive balance tax implications, and the future of contract negotiations in MLB. However, Ohtani’s contract is a testament to his commitment to winning and the Dodgers’ ability to attract top talent. Only time will tell if this groundbreaking contract becomes a model for future free agents or an anomaly in MLB history.
For more articles like this click here.
